Some Questions about Medication vs. Herbal/Dietary Changes

This is where you can discuss all matters related to natural healing methods and natural remedies for Crohn's, Colitis, Diverticulitis and Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS). Also, any other related topics of interest. Discuss your experiences, ideas, questions. Request a Healing Journey Buddy, or any other kind of support you may want.

NOTE: If you are a JPT Gold or Platinum member, then Dr. Silvio Najt, MD, would like to invite you to join him in a bi-weekly support/discussion group for those with IBD or IBS.

Dr. Najt would like this to be a time of exploration, problem-solving and support for those of you on a Healing Journey. There is no fee for participation - it is one of the benefits of JPT membership: http://www.JPTwellnessCircle.com

This forum is for public discussion with others interested in natural protocols. If you want to have Jini Patel Thompson, Nicole Paull, or Dr. Silvio Najt answer your question, you need to become a Platinum Member of JPT Wellness Circle and use the private forum at that website: http://www.jptwellnesscircle.com

Some Questions about Medication vs. Herbal/Dietary Changes

Postby Mmirza on Tue Mar 25, 2008 4:02 am

Hi,
I am new to the forum and had some general questions. I am a 28 year old man and I've had Crohn's Disease for about 13 years. I've been on alot of different medications throughout this time. I recently stopped taking Entacort just last week (which is a steroid like Prednisone) and am currently still taking Pentasa (16 pills per day) and Remicaide every 6 weeks....so as you can see my medication is still quite intense.

I am lucky though because my girlfriend has been very supportive of helping me manage my Crohns...she is actually the one who told me about Jini. I ordered the book a couple of weeks ago and have really enjoyed reading it...it is giving me alot of hope to get off my medications.

I had a colonscopy on Thursday and my GI told me that I have inflamed polyps which is probably the cause of my recent discomfort. Do you think that Jini's dietary changes will help control these polyps? I was a little bit discouraged and feeling bad because I mentioned Jini's book to him and possible herbal/dietary changes and he did not seem supportive of these alternatives at all, which bothered me at the time. Has anyone else encountered this lack of support from their GI?

My GI also suggested that I start taking Boniva. This concerns me a bit because I was under the impression that Boniva is more for woman who are going through menopause...and I wasnt sure if men should be taking it as well. Does anyone here have any input on if there should be any concern for a man taking Boniva?

I apologize if these questions seem a bit silly, but there is so much information out there it is a bit difficult to get a handle on everything. I've been a bit lazy about my health for all these years and now I am just trying to be proactive so I can lead a healthier life and reduce some of the worries of my girlfriend.

Any insight into those questions would be greatly appreciated!

thanks,
Mo
Mmirza
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Mar 20, 2008 11:26 pm
Location: Boston, MA

Postby Nicole on Tue Mar 25, 2008 6:08 pm

Hi, Mo.

Yes, holistic therapy for IBD can be extremely effective, but the catch is that the best results come from a multi-pronged strategy. That doesn't mean you need to start implementing everything at once - this can be done incrementally - but you need to have in your mind the commitment successful holistic healing requires.

I'd look for a naturopath who has experience with digestive issues to be on your team while you wean from medications (assuming this is what you want to do).

Yes, it is very common to experience a reaction like your doctor's - medical doctors don't have training in natural therapies for one thing, even a lot of medical schools receive a significant amount of funding from pharmaceutical companies, so you can see where their emphasis lies. Additionally, most doctors probably see people who try to implement an herbal therapy the way they would a drug.

Holistic healing does not work that way. If you take an herb for a particular symptom but don't support its actions by eating well, getting sufficient rest, addressing any stressors, etc., well, you're not going to see the same results as if you're implementing the full strategy.

You can check on Boniva by doing some online research. A couple of websites are www.webmd.com and www.drugs.com. Another one is www.askapatient.com.

Hope that helps.

Nicole
Nicole Paull is a health writer and concerned mother. She is not a registered health professional nor doctor of any sort. The information in this forum posting is simply her own personal opinion. Any action, or inaction taken as a result, is entirely at your own risk and liability.

She healed her Crohn's using the protocols in "Listen To Your Gut" and has been in remission for over a year: http://www.crohnsalternative.com
The supplements Nicole uses and recommends (unless otherwise stated) can be found at: http://www.HolisticHealthShoppe.com
Nicole
Site Admin
 
Posts: 711
Joined: Wed May 31, 2006 7:42 pm
Location: New England

Postby luvrgrrl on Wed Mar 26, 2008 1:26 am

Hi, Mo. Welcome to the forum!

Just wanted to comment on your question about GI doctors in general. YES, I have found them to be extremely un-supportive when it comes to holistic therapies. I've had four GI doctors and only one of them has expressed even the slightest interest in the holistic approaches I have tried. Even when I tell them they have WORKED for me! You would think they would want to know, but I have found that they are so one-tracked in their thinking, (and snobbish about allopathic medicine), that they won't give you the time of day. Of course, I am speaking in general and from my experiences- I am sure there are some excellent GI's out there who are open-minded.

My approach is to take everything the GI says with a grain of salt, then decide for myself what's right for my body. Sometimes I am wrong, but at least I am making the effort to listen to my body.

Hang in there- and as Nicole says, if you can find a naturopath it would be a great thing.

Tara
"Do Well & Doubt Not"
luvrgrrl
 
Posts: 28
Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2007 3:21 pm
Location: Antioch, CA

Postby Mmirza on Wed Mar 26, 2008 11:28 pm

thanks Nicole and Tara for the responses, I appreciate it! I think I will look into Naturopaths. I did a brief google search and found quite a few that are actually pretty close to where I work...I had no idea :) I'm not sure if they specialize in stomach related issues but I guess that will be the next step by contacting them.
Thanks again for the good info!
Regards
-Mo
Mmirza
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Mar 20, 2008 11:26 pm
Location: Boston, MA

Postby Nicole on Thu Mar 27, 2008 12:17 pm

Hi, Mo.

Do make sure you research the particular naturopaths, as well.

A couple of good places you can check their credentials are:

The American Association of Naturopathic Physicians
www.naturopathic.org

American Naturopathic Medical Association
www.anma.com

One doctor I have consulted with personally, who is both an MD and an ND is Carolyn Dean. You can learn more about her at www.carolyndean.com.

Take care,
Nicole
Nicole Paull is a health writer and concerned mother. She is not a registered health professional nor doctor of any sort. The information in this forum posting is simply her own personal opinion. Any action, or inaction taken as a result, is entirely at your own risk and liability.

She healed her Crohn's using the protocols in "Listen To Your Gut" and has been in remission for over a year: http://www.crohnsalternative.com
The supplements Nicole uses and recommends (unless otherwise stated) can be found at: http://www.HolisticHealthShoppe.com
Nicole
Site Admin
 
Posts: 711
Joined: Wed May 31, 2006 7:42 pm
Location: New England


Return to Main Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests