Ascorbic Acid in Emergen-C - Is it Still Safe?

This is where you can discuss all matters related to natural healing methods and natural remedies for Crohn's, Colitis, Diverticulitis and Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS). Also, any other related topics of interest. Discuss your experiences, ideas, questions. Request a Healing Journey Buddy, or any other kind of support you may want.

NOTE: If you are a JPT Gold or Platinum member, then Dr. Silvio Najt, MD, would like to invite you to join him in a bi-weekly support/discussion group for those with IBD or IBS.

Dr. Najt would like this to be a time of exploration, problem-solving and support for those of you on a Healing Journey. There is no fee for participation - it is one of the benefits of JPT membership: http://www.JPTwellnessCircle.com

This forum is for public discussion with others interested in natural protocols. If you want to have Jini Patel Thompson, Nicole Paull, or Dr. Silvio Najt answer your question, you need to become a Platinum Member of JPT Wellness Circle and use the private forum at that website: http://www.jptwellnesscircle.com

Ascorbic Acid in Emergen-C - Is it Still Safe?

Postby Aria'sMom on Fri Jun 15, 2007 6:20 am

I noticed the Vitamin C in the Emergen-C packets is listed:

(as ascorbic acid, zinc ascorbate, and chromium ascorbate)

Isn't the ascorbic acid contraindicated for IBD sufferers?

Heather
Aria'sMom
 
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Jun 14, 2007 5:05 am

Postby Nicole on Sat Jun 16, 2007 7:31 pm

Hi, Heather.

That's a good question and I have noticed the same thing on the labels.

Yes, you are correct, too much ascorbic acid will exacerbate diarrhea.

In lieu of contacting the manufacturer and asking for clarification (since the box says 7 different Mineral Ascorbates but the Nutrition Facts include ascorbic acid on several of the flavors), I encourage you to let her try the Emergen-C and see how she responds to it.

I am also diagnosed with Crohn's but I usually have at least two packets of Emergen-C each day and sometimes as many as six or seven (if I have a cold, for instance). I find that my body has no problem at all with this.

It's good.....in fact, crucial.....to educate ourselves, as long as we remember that in the end, it is our own bodies that are going to give us our best information on our healing journeys. Your daughter will be able to tell you, very quickly, whether the Emergen-C is a good thing for her or not.

Nicole
Nicole
Site Admin
 
Posts: 711
Joined: Wed May 31, 2006 7:42 pm
Location: New England

Postby Nicole on Wed Dec 19, 2007 3:24 pm

This came up again recently and Jini contacted Alacer, so thought I would share it here for everyone's benefit:


I just talked to Alacer and here's what they said: The ingredients for Emergen-C have actually remained the same, however, due to changes in labeling laws, they now have to list it differently. So here's what happens, as soon as you add water to Emergen-C, the ascorbic acid is converted into mineral ascorbates due to the presence of sodium
bicarbonate.

If you do research on the Internet, you'll see that a common recipe
for vitamin C in ascorbate form is to take ascorbic acid, then add
baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) and water.

So go ahead, but still keep in mind the other things I pointed out -
like taking divided doses, not too much at once, drinking slowly, etc.


Hope this helps!

Nicole
Nicole Paull is a health writer and concerned mother. She is not a registered health professional nor doctor of any sort. The information in this forum posting is simply her own personal opinion. Any action, or inaction taken as a result, is entirely at your own risk and liability.

She healed her Crohn's using the protocols in "Listen To Your Gut" and has been in remission for over a year: http://www.crohnsalternative.com
The supplements Nicole uses and recommends (unless otherwise stated) can be found at: http://www.HolisticHealthShoppe.com
Nicole
Site Admin
 
Posts: 711
Joined: Wed May 31, 2006 7:42 pm
Location: New England


Return to Main Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest